In the beginning there was judging…

August 7th, 2007

Sasha's TableThis year I had the opportunity to be an aesthetic judge for the cheese society competition. There were more cheeses entered than ever before and thus more judges too. The cheese categories were divided among 15 teams of judges- each team has a technical and aesthetic judge. A division of labor in the evaluation of the cheese- the technical judge is looking for flaws and the aesthetic judge is looking for everything that is good about the cheese (aromas, flavor, texture, and rind/appearance). The technical judges start with 50 points and deduct while the aesthetic judges build up points to a maximum of 50.We started out the first day with a training session where John Greeley and David Grotenstein (the competition co-chairs) explained the judging protocols of the American Cheese Society. Then we did a trial run of five cheeses, comparing our scoring and comments to ensure that we all understood how to put our judging sheets into practice. The teams were announced, our white lab coats were issued and we were unleashed on our tables.

Bob Bradley was my technical partner. He is a retired professor and researcher from the University of Wisconsin. I thoroughlyBob's Table enjoyed working alongside him- he’s got some serious cheese evaluation skills- figures considering he was the coach of the Dairy Products Evaluation Team for years in Wisconsin. The coolest thing about Bob though was that he was that rare combination of confident and curious. When I didn’t taste things that he did, we would discuss it at length- not necessarily to alter our scores but to understand each other’s palette. Of course these conversations mostly ended in a litany of questions from me to him about the science happening in cheese when it is made and during its maturation.

Each cheese is marked with an alphanumeric code- you can see them on the stickers in the photo. This prevents the judges from knowing for certain what any individual cheese is, who it was made by, etc. Bob and I would taste each cheese together- discuss- complete our judging sheets separately and then move on to the next. A lot of people have asked me about spitting- I found that it didn’t make much of a difference because you’re not taking big bites or many bites of each cheese and spitting out a mouthful of food into a bucket just didn’t work for me. So I pretty much fully ate all of them.

Later on in the second day of judging I got a tour from the staff who had coordinated the receiving and organization of the 1200+ cheeses thatBob with cheese trier were in the competition. Boxes started rolling in the Thursday before the conference and were received in cold room, sorted by shipping company, opened, and the cheeses were placed on rolling racks. [Note- the cheesemakers received their alphanumeric coded stickers in advance and submitted the cheeses to the competition without any labeling except for the sticker.] The racks were then wheeled out back to four large walk in refrigerated trailers that were labeled with groups of categories. The cheeses left their first rack to be sorted into their appropriate categories.

Any boxes that were wet, crushed, or damaged in some way went immediately to the triage station where they were photographed inside and out, internal temps were taken on the cheeses and in cases where there was enough concern they were tasted and evaluated before being announced damaged. If I remember correctly, Debra Dickerson (the woman who works her rear off on this coordination each year) said that there was only one instance where they contacted the cheesemaker and gave them the option to resubmit.

Within any given category there could be 8 oz. pieces and 40 lb blocks so the small pieces were put on trays towards the top, big blocks and wheels at the bottom and tempering charts were drawn up so that the judges would ideally have all the cheeses at the correct temp during evaluations. Totally, ridiculously impressive.

It is important to give credit to two less visible people who made this level of logistics possible- Karen and Richard Silverston. They sat down with the teams who put on the competition each year and picked their brains thoroughly to develop a database and data entry sheets and screens for every possible scenario. The beauty of this is that every piece of cheese received is tracked all the way through the process and the tabulation of scores is much faster than in previous years.

The judging culminates with the selection of the Best in Show. They used a new process this year where the first place winner in each category was set out on the tables and all 75 of them were tasted by all judges. To earn first place in any category a cheese must score over 91 points (so some categories don’t have first place winners), second place must earn at least 81 and third place must score over 75 points. So at the end of day two of tasting 65+ cheeses, the judges circulated on their own to taste all 75 blue ribbon winners and select three cheeses (ranked in their order of preference) for best in show.

In previous years there was only one Best in Show cheese- this year they decided to acknowledge 2nd and 3rd place in this overall category. My approach was to give everything I tasted either a 1, 2, or 3 and then to re-taste and consider only those cheeses with 3 points. We knew the winner about one hour after the cheeses were ready for us to taste. While all of the judges likely have suggestions about things that could be tweaked in the judging- we were universally impressed by the care and organization it took to run a tasting of this size.

Check out results on the ACS website!

Entry Filed under: Travel, Ruminations

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed


Calendar

August 2014
M T W T F S S
« Jun    
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Most Recent Posts


  • difference between and
  • abuse weight loss
  • mesren v
  • free sample 24hr
  • memory issues
  • ibs dose
  • oftalmik damla
  • children dosage
  • tablets rxlist
  • when will be available over the counter
  • product monograph canada
  • chibro libido
  • during breastfeeding
  • can treat boils
  • causing itching
  • xr side effects
  • hydrocodone
  • para que se usa el medicamento
  • cause irritability
  • can you take sudafed and d
  • during 1st trimester
  • recall 2009
  • stomach acid
  • is a beta lactam
  • para que sirve la yahoo respuestas
  • can you just stop taking
  • cardioselective
  • antidepressant discontinuation syndrome
  • aurochem
  • d'8
  • pseudomonas sensitive
  • tmj pain
  • sr skutki uboczne
  • can you take together
  • and interaction
  • anxiety elderly
  • wart medication
  • do lower blood pressure
  • e minoxidil
  • efectos secundarios 75 mg
  • na alergie
  • border hours
  • lawsuits florida
  • a kwas foliowy
  • side effects in men
  • muscle aches withdrawal
  • otc drug
  • quick does work
  • buy generic online
  • e gestaAžA?o
  • rate credit on bge bill
  • can you take benadryl
  • lek
  • rite aid pharmacy
  • withdrawal symptoms insomnia
  • kidney pain
  • para que es el
  • spotting
  • poco sangrado despues de
  • sirop posologie
  • panadol
  • buy in us
  • can take tylenol pm
  • dean k
  • has my stopped working
  • and leg pain
  • can i take when i am pregnant
  • oral uses
  • food allergy
  • e mestruazioni
  • time to start working
  • oily discharge
  • buy online
  • liquid dosage
  • time to take effect
  • maximum dosage of daily
  • trop de
  • otc safe long term use
  • cream overdose
  • dosage instructions
  • causing depression
  • starting after a miscarriage
  • vs
  • injection
  • benadryl interactions
  • antabus interactions
  • odpowiedniki
  • renal failure
  • taking
  • happens if stop taking my
  • pregnancy side effects
  • is used to treat acne
  • kart
  • can i take while pregnant
  • 500 mg 50 tb
  • s\/a corretora de cA?mbio
  • rezeptfrei in deutschland
  • zoloft switch
  • can cause loss of appetite
  • lc service &
  • chest pain side effects
  • 800 mg
  • applying cream
  • can take while nursing
  • fever
  • safe for infants
  • 5395975069
  • does make yeast infection worse
  • can i take cold medicine while on
  • eating disorder
  • jak brac po mecie
  • high blood pressure side effects
  • vs
  • therapeutic action
  • need help paying
  • how long after taking are you contagious
  • antidepressant side effects
  • can my child take and together
  • dianabol
  • losing potency
  • ndc
  • novartis patient assistance program
  • will test positive for methamphetamine
  • sirve para bajar de peso
  • can you stop
  • 40 mg
  • preAžo do remedio 5mg
  • dosage chemotherapy
  • interaction
  • can take kidney infection
  • and liver enzymes
  • treat staph
  • provigil wellbutrin
  • side effects skin
  • should you take with food
  • chart
  • interaction between
  • compare tinactin
  • feet swelling
  • cures candida
  • in the news
  • treatment pid
  • and
  • missed dose
  • other uses
  • normal dosage uti
  • is safe for pregnancy
  • mg dosage
  • que es el
  • voucher
  • blood monitoring
  • hct recall
  • before urine test
  • using acne
  • eljo
  • mast
  • free trial
  • blood thinner
  • buy d uk
  • reactions
  • safe dose range
  • muscle pain
  • what does it look like
  • effects kidney function
  • 30 mg dosage
  • or
  • side effects nightmares
  • milligrams does come
  • used eating disorders
  • can you take together
  • do you need prescription uk
  • when was relief launched
  • 80 mg
  • iv compatibility
  • taper off
  • can mixed solution
  • 150 mg side effects
  • 5 mg lilly fta 28 st
  • what are the side effects of going off
  • annual sales
  • prescription only
  • average dose
  • type b flu
  • can kids take and together
  • why give at bedtime
  • 20 mg used for
  • cream recall
  • kadA▒nlar kulA?bA?
  • mega red krill oil
  • can u take advil
  • is gluten free
  • gastrin
  • healthy baby
  • vs
  • crema v para sirve
  • sepeda motor
  • late ovulation on bfp
  • can you crush cr
  • enablex
  • best skin care while on
  • follicles on day 12
  • yeast infection
  • expired pregnancy
  • ointment
  • if stops working
  • usage
  • 8 mg kaufen
  • hct missed dose
  • online
  • ingredients
  • edad se tomar
  • 8267343161
  • can you take with hct
  • can take advil together
  • guaifenesin d
  • allergy medication
  • pharmacological classification
  • for restless leg syndrome side effects
  • y maca
  • a spA?A?niony okres
  • alternatives
  • as a mood stabilizer
  • how long does it take for to work
  • tabletten wirkung
  • erectile dysfunction
  • used for anxiety
  • taking empty stomach
  • amazon
  • para verme
  • low progesterone while taking
  • reviews
  • for for cold sores
  • special offers
  • usage
  • 2224291683
  • xanax interactions
  • medication discounts
  • interactions drugs
  • 7323917684
  • i took 20mg of
  • side effects joints
  • 1 g iv
  • do you need prescription for in australia
  • 956230504
  • buy cheap uk
  • effects liver
  • pseudomonas resistance
  • unterschied
  • migraine treatment
  • generico farmacia italia
  • cost target
  • for men
  • age limit
  • invega conversion
  • eczema
  • cream while breastfeeding
  • e dimagrimento
  • is safe while breastfeeding
  • musicians
  • auckland
  • children's cvs
  • time to take effect
  • description
  • for a 12 year old
  • polycystic ovarian syndrome-treatment with
  • cheapest canada
  • class action lawsuit
  • 4 gel
  • oral contraceptives
  • c'est quoi le
  • 300 generic
  • low sperm count
  • and success stories
  • on drug testing
  • safer
  • for back pain
  • for osteopenia
  • safe during pregnancy
  • low dose weight loss
  • type drug
  • cr itching
  • user guide
  • for 2 yr old
  • does make you bigger than normal
  • and ritalin
  • l lysine
  • l-tryptophan und
  • flexeril vs
  • l effet secondaire
  • prostate drug
  • do you have to take daily
  • cream pregnancy
  • will reduce my milk supply
  • related sulfa drugs
  • valium
  • biglietti per italia a parma
  • sr bula
  • beaumont football club
  • side effects heart palpitations
  • natural supplement works like
  • can you take on an empty stomach
  • will help premature ejaculation
  • gynecomastia
  • drug class
  • with
  • alternative cvs
  • and peeling rash
  • banda
  • agitation anxiety
  • ambien drug interactions
  • y engordar
  • important safety information
  • can i get over the counter
  • high
  • coupon
  • zomig
  • a bangkok
  • sintomas despues aborto provocado
  • pictures of all pills
  • serotonin antagonist
  • same
  • get period after
  • prescription drug
  • a wymioty
  • n aerozol wziewny
  • vitamin d
  • health canada
  • cr 37.5mg
  • dresden il
  • r capsulas 300 mg
  • upper abdominal pain
  • can you take and benadryl together
  • used treat
  • anxiety
  • breastfeeding no period
  • xarope posologia
  • difference between levo sodium
  • tablets how to use
  • will interfere birth control
  • side effects blogs
  • price canada
  • famine maleate 50 mg
  • suspension
  • 24 hour
  • toxicity in children
  • que es la pastilla
  • for dilated cardiomyopathy
  • use
  • et cancer
  • ampolla embarazo
  • septic aerator
  • abuse potential
  • can a toddler take and tylenol together
  • indications
  • and together
  • hand tremors
  • 20 mg bula
  • can cause miscarriage
  • single dose gonorrhea
  • cheap 100mg
  • how much to cure chlamydia
  • purpose
  • y pastillas anticonceptivas
  • still available usa
  • xarope infarmed
  • taking and together
  • vs diamicron
  • i dojenje
  • dosage
  • can take z pack together
  • turisti x caso
  • is zoloft better than for anxiety
  • hallucinations
  • gives me gas
  • yeast infection one dose
  • canine colitis
  • or
  • for premature ejaculation
  • side effects hallucinations
  • free samples
  • acne
  • jarabe infantil
  • same time
  • allergic reaction side effects
  • used for depression
  • when will i ovulate taking days 5-9
  • plant locations
  • para que sirve
  • is out of date safe
  • does it get worse before it gets better
  • otc
  • will make you sleepy
  • pizzarium roma
  • 30 ct
  • dependent factors
  • what does it look like
  • is 150mg of a high dose
  • 2 stA?ck
  • buy overnight delivery
  • lose weight after